Tire iron vs lug wrench
Wrenches are tools that are used for turning objects, usually to tighten or loosen their grip on something. These can be done on various screws or nuts. There are two types of wrenches, the open-end wrench, and the socket wrench.
The tire iron (or tire lever) is shaped like an elongated triangle but may vary depending on the manufacturer. It has two ends; one end is hooked while the other end has prying blades. You use this tool to help in removing tires by slipping the hooked end of the tire iron under the edge of the tire bead and prying it off.
What is tire iron used for?
The tire iron is used in taking off and putting on tires and rims. The pointed end is used to pry the tire off, while the other end is used to lift up the rim.
Types of tire iron
There are different kinds of the tire iron, but most often they are all made of steel.
Tire iron advantages:
- Tire irons are narrower, which allows you to slip them between the tire bead and rims without grabbing too much of the tire at once. Lug wrenches are much wider, which means that if they are not long enough, it can be difficult to get enough torque to tighten or loosen lug nuts.
- A tire iron is also made of thinner material than a lug wrench. This allows for less leverage with your grip when using one. Even with both arms fully extended, the metal in most tire levers is so thin that even normal strength will provide more force than with most lug wrenches where you have to use both hands just to increase your leverage.
- The hooked end of a tire iron lets you apply and remove pressure on the bead of the tire without deforming it like lug wrenches with hooks can do. With a lug wrench, if you don’t hold both ends or use something else to hold open the hook, chances are that it will deform your rim when you try to tighten or loosen lug nuts. Lug wrenches with smooth-sided hooks such as most bicycle levers don’t cause this problem because they spread out force over larger areas than just one point.
- Tire irons can be shaped so that their inside corner is sharp enough for prying things loose, but not so sharp as to cut yourself and liability issues and they come in both thin and thick materials depending on what you need it for.
- Tire irons can be used to cut wire or remove nails from tires so that they won’t puncture your new tire when you use it again after replacing the flat one and getting some air in it.
Tire iron disadvantages:
- Since their hook is usually located at the end instead of on the sides, there is a higher chance of the hook slipping off the bead if you apply pressure on it at an angle. This is not usually a problem with lug wrenches because they have two parallel hooks which means that as long as one of them is underneath the bead, as little as half a turn will tighten or loosen it so that there’s no risk of it coming loose.
- A tire iron takes up more space in your car than a lug wrench does and can be easily lost since they come apart and sometimes even fold inside your trunk space if you’re using something like an SUV.
What is a lug wrench used for?
A lug wrench, on the other hand, is used in tightening and loosening the lug nuts of your tires. It is shaped like an L with arms sticking out from both sides along with a knob at one end that you use to turn it. The rotor or other parts are then attached to the wheel lugs that can be easily fastened by rotating the lugs clockwise until they are tight enough before hammering them down.
The lug wrench is also known as a socket wrench because it has sockets to fit various different sized nuts or screws, depending on if you are using an impact-type or fixed-torque type lug wrench. Lug wrenches are mostly used in automobiles but can also be used for industrial machinery if they have lug nuts that need tightening or loosening.
The sockets on both types of wrenches come in either metric or SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers) measurements, each with its own set series. The only difference between the two is the way their sizes are written. They are most commonly found in 3/8″ or 5/16″ sizes for Americans, but can also be found in 1/4″, 7mm, 8 mm, 10 mm, 12 mm, 14mm, and 17 mm sizes for the metric system.
Types of lug wrenches
There are different kinds of lug wrenches depending on how you tighten or loosen the lug nuts. They are usually either impact-type or fixed-torque types.
- An impact-type wrench is when the torque in tightening your lug nuts is done with an electric drill that is used in conjunction with a socket attached to the end of the handle.
- A fixed-torque type, on the other hand, has no way of adjusting torque which means that if you try to use it in low torque situations such as motorcycle wheels, chances are high that they will round out your lugs before they reach proper tightness levels. This issue can be avoided by not using them with motorcycle wheels or any other vehicle without lugs that have a recessed area to fit the “box end” of the wrench.
A fixed-torque type can also be used on vehicles with lugs that don’t require tightening or loosening, such as on some commercial truck wheels, but are not recommended for use on vehicles where lugs need to undergo reliability changes in tightness levels throughout their lifespan.
Lug wrench advantages:
- It can be used both to tighten and loosen lug nuts, unlike tire levers which only work for one side. This gives you complete control over the lug nuts at all times instead of having to worry about them coming loose before you’re done tightening or after you’ve finished loosening them. It also decreases the chance of a tire falling off while driving which could result in a terrible accident.
- Lug wrenches are usually made from very sturdy metal materials because their primary function is to leverage force on tight-fitting parts against heavy tension without breaking. They usually come with both metric and SAE measurements so that they can fit any vehicle regardless of make or model as long as it uses lug nuts . Most manufacturers label their products with the dimensions on the box it comes in, which saves you a lot of time and energy instead of having to measure each one.
- Lug wrenches come with a T-bar that allows you to hammer them down onto the lug nuts instead of having to worry about your feet slipping from underneath them while trying to hold the wrench steady. This is an effective way to get more leverage on any tight-fitting nut or bolt without risking injury or damaging the surrounding area even further since hammers tend to cause a lot of collateral damage when being used at close quarters.
Lug wrench disadvantages:
- Because they come in both metric and SAE measurements, lug wrenches have a higher price range than irons do because they are generally more expensive to make which gives you the added advantage of paying less for your irons.
- Lug wrenches are also bigger in size compared to tire irons because they need the leverage on tight-fitting lugs which means that it’s harder to maneuver them into smaller spaces. They can be awkward and cumbersome when trying to use them in tight corners or underneath your car, whereas iron is more lightweight and easier to handle on tough terrain where lug wrenches simply cannot fit.
What is the difference between a lug wrench and a tire iron?
A lug wrench is longer than the usual tire irons you see in shops – this can be compared to how some crowbars are larger than others. Lug wrenches come with different heads that fit on different types of lugs or nuts depending on what vehicle you have. Lug wrenches prevent your hands from getting dirty since it serves as both tools for tightening and loosening nuts on wheels so you won’t need another tool like a tire iron. It also prevents damages to the lugs, unlike tire irons which can cause damage to the nuts or lug studs.
Lug wrenches are more sturdy than tire irons because they are used for heavy-duty jobs so the material is made from tough metal that gives it added durability and sturdiness. The size of a lug wrench makes them ideal to be used with large trucks, SUVs, and buses while tire irons are smaller in size – this allows you to use them on small cars that don’t need lug nut removal since their wheels already come off easily.
Lug wrenches are sturdier, longer, and more durable than tire irons. Since they give you additional leverage on loose-fitting lugs that need to be turned by hand, it’s easier to get them started without having to worry about hurting your hands. Lug wrenches are also useful for jobs where there is a lot of dirt involved since the handle is T-shaped which means that you don’t have to bend down as much or get your hands dirty.
Tire irons are smaller in size but can still do the same things as lug wrenches, which makes them preferable especially if you’re working on small cars with smaller wheels that use nuts instead of studs. Because both tools serve the same purpose, the choice will always be yours on which one to use since both of them are effective at getting tight-fitting lugs loose and vice versa.